Brand development that increases sales velocity, guaranteed.

Successful Packaging Design Isnt a Commodity

Does your packaging design company get all excited at the thought of quantitative research? Will your design team spend hours deciphering hundreds of pages of statistical data? Do your designers deeply love graphs? If the answer is no, you might want to rethink your packaging design associates.

Consumer appeal isn’t accidental; a huge amount of detailed study is involved in determining which marketing strategies will succeed and which will likely fail. Beautiful and trendy design alone doesn’t always work — as much as it pains us to admit it. Sadly, the general population sometimes just doesn’t embrace good taste, as the blitz popularity of “Gangnam Style” will tell you.

Winning packaging design is far more than the mere conceptualization of packaging structures and eye-pleasing graphic designs; it involves vigorous and in-depth market analysis. After all, you want your package to sell your product, and if the factors that contribute to consumer appeal remain a mystery, your product will remain on store shelves indefinitely, no matter how great it is or how beautifully designed the package.

What is involved in packaging design research, anyway? How does a company — particularly a new company — determine what will or will not speak to the largest number of customers? Here are a few of the crucial tactics involved in demystifying consumer buying habits.

Demographic Isolation

Where is your product sold, and what retailers carry it? Furthermore, what sort of customers typically shop at the retail outlets that carry your products? What other products are popular with your demographic, and what do their brand identities communicate?

Even if you want your products to be the darling of prestige retailers, if the fact is that it is more likely to be sold at 7-Eleven than Bristol Farms, you have to encourage the 7-Eleven demographic to reach for it, and their needs and desires are very different from the locally sourced, sustainable and organic crowd.

Ethnography

What are the cultural influencers that dictate the buying habits of your target demographic? Are they more likely to scrutinize the package label, or do they grab whatever is the cheapest? Which products are the most popular amongst this particular subgroup, and why?

In Depth, One-on-one Interviews

Interviewing individual customers about their buying habits can yield mountains of useful information — perhaps more so than design focus groups. During individual interviews, customers aren’t influenced by the sentiment of the group, and they are given the opportunity to delineate their particular habits freely and in great detail.

When consumers feel as though they are an integral part of the design process, they can engage quite enthusiastically with the brand. Customers like to feel as though their concerns and desires are being heard, and this can go far in developing your brand identity.

Focus Groups

Design focus groups are especially good for established brands, since they are more likely to be familiar with their brand identity, and will therefore deliver relevant information about their experiences with that brand’s products. However, one does have to be careful about focus groups, because an unfortunate reality of focus groups is group-think; if one or two members of the group exhibit particularly strong opinions, then that can affect the responses of the rest, and these responses might not reflect their actual habits. Moreover, some members of focus groups are just in it for the money or whatever other incentives that led them to the room. Imagine!

It is hugely important to have an experienced and knowledgeable moderator for focus groups in order to glean the most accurate results. Focus groups are especially helpful at the last stages of packaging development, when the strategies are ready to be put into practice.

When you’re unveiling a new product or reconfiguring the packaging strategy for an existing product, you have know your consumer desires backwards and forwards if you want your results to sing. The proper packaging design research strategies could make the difference between a pretty package and a package that sells.

Subscribe to
Nice Package.

SmashBrand’s Nice Package: Stay current with our latest insights

Free Resource.
CPG product repositioning guide.
CPG product repositioning guide.

Explore the five undeniable signs your CPG product needs repositioning along with strategies for leveraging consumer insights for a guaranteed market lift.

Download Whitepaper About CPG product repositioning guide.

More from SmashBrand

NICE PACKAGE, Design

The Problem with Packaging Design That Looks Different.

Most brands chase standout visuals without asking a harder question, does it make the product easier to recognize and buy? That gap kills performance. If your design stands out but doesn’t convert, it’s failing. Want to see why? Read on.

Category Insights, Shopping With Christy

Why Rao’s Soup Misses the Mark on This Packaging Design.

Brand extension can be a powerful growth strategy, but only if it’s executed with clarity. In this case, the transition from pasta sauce into soup creates confusion rather than differentiation. The biggest issue is visual overlap. Using the same jar, color palette, and overall look as the pasta sauce line makes it difficult to immediately…

Category Insights

This Retail Display Tells You Everything About a Brand in Trouble

When packaging starts working against the brand, it shows up quickly, especially on the shelf. In this case, the execution creates confusion instead of clarity. The most immediate issue is readability. If shoppers can’t quickly identify the brand name or fully read the tagline, the pack loses its primary job: recognition. “Thirst’s worst” is a…

Category Insights

Why This Parent and CPG Marketer Secretly Loves This “White” Bread

Sometimes the most powerful packaging change is verbal. A single line of copy can unlock the entire value proposition. In this case, the product already solved a real consumer tension: the desire for healthier bread that still feels and tastes like white bread. But previously, that benefit was implied rather than stated. Shoppers had to…

Category Insights

Wait, Sargento Makes Crackers Now? Not Exactly

Brand extensions only work when trust transfers seamlessly, and that’s where this execution creates friction. At first glance, the product signals cheese, not crackers. The name, visuals, and dominant cues all lean heavily into cheese equity, leaving the actual product format unclear. That confusion matters. Shoppers rely on quick recognition, and if they can’t immediately…

Category Insights

Is Coke Lime making a Comeback?

Limited-time innovation only works if timing and design align with consumer expectations. A citrus-forward cola immediately signals refreshment, which is typically associated with warmer months. Launching that profile in October creates a subtle disconnect, even if the execution is strong. From a strategy standpoint, this is a classic line extension play, leveraging an existing brand…