Brand development that increases sales velocity, guaranteed.

Where’s the Line between Creative and Kitschy.

Johnny Cash made the expression to “walk the line” one of our most popular shared cultural references. As crucial as finding balance is, it’s as difficult to achieve in packaging design as in our daily lives. But the Man in Black had a point: straying too far in one direction or the other can have disastrous consequences. While kitsch can be a way into mass appeal, especially in a culture ruled by hipsters who cherish anything a sane person might deem low-brow or outdated, the line between being genuinely creative and insufferably kitschy is as sharp as a razor.

If we assume that the simplest approach is right, then keeping it simple may not be so stupid. When creative packaging design is the goal, sometimes going big is the answer. But how do you know when you’ve got just enough before you cross the line to too much? Let’s look at how creativity in packaging design can be attention-grabbing without crossing the line into off-putting.

Get your Hands on the SmashReport!

And enter to win a FREE brand diagnosis worth $20,000.

*The SmashReport is a monthly newsletter for FMCG and CPG brands, helping them stand out in the competitive retail marketplace.

* indicates required

Finger-Licking Good?

The first culprit in our lineup of line-crossing offenders is this ham-fisted attempt at creative packaging design. This package for pork sausages takes the brand’s “hand-reared pork” slogan a little too literally. For a processed meat product generally comprised of the leftover bits of a pig’s anatomy, once the good stuff is butchered for chops, loins, and bacon, is it wise to bring fingers into the picture? Pigs don’t have fingers, but this example of creative packaging design on steroids is enough to make you want to bring up your lunch. While we applaud the designer’s efforts to think outside the box, we’d sooner buy this product were it packaged in unmarked cardboard rather than this digit-ally enhanced container.

Fruit, Yet Not Fruit

While the above example engages our taste buds in an off-putting way, on the other side of the line is this example of fruit juice packages that incorporate the fruits themselves to make the contents seem mouthwatering. It would be difficult to resist the temptation to pop the straw and dig into these gorgeously packaged banana, strawberry, and coconut juices. The designer created a functional container that is as visually appealing as it is simple, proving that the line can be successfully navigated without perpetrating a gastronomical misdemeanor that may drive away more customers than it entices.

Help without Crossing the Line

We love this packaging designer’s fun creating interesting, informative, and eye-catching cases for various generic over-the-counter medications. By designing a series of packages for pills for various ailments, the designer has simultaneously created a collectable series of medicine boxes. Getting straight to the point with clear taglines like “help, I have an aching body” so buyers can avoid the complicated verbiage that often makes up medication labels, these nifty little containers are so cute it’s easy to convince consumers to pick up a couple extras just in case. They’re just kitschy enough to be appealing in a cute way without crossing the line or going too far. It’s a clever way to integrate smart, simple, clean lines into a creative packaging design while enticing consumers to collect multiple product iterations.

And finally, to prove the point that it’s possible to integrate the human anatomy into food packaging without creating a stomach-turning result like the finger fiasco above, we have our final entry into our exploration of the fine line between creativity and kitsch: this eye-catching, funny, and aspirational packaging for high-protein sandwich bread.

This designer found a cheeky and interesting way to link the product’s intended purpose (helping consumers grow muscles by eating high-protein ingredients) into its packaging. Silly? Yes. Clever? Definitely. And the best part is that it’s not even about the bread — it was a marketing effort to get people into a chain of fitness studios! It’s a fine line, as we’ve seen, but the only gastronomical impulse this packaging elicits is a belly laugh… not a vomit reflex. We give it flying colors on the creativity index.

Data-Driven Brand Development

Want a best-selling brand? SmashBrand is a brand development company for FMCG and CPG brands. From brand strategy to packaging design testing, our Path To Performance™ process guarantees a retail performance lift. Book a time to discuss your project with our team.

Subscribe to
Nice Package.

A monthly newsletter that unpacks a critical topic in the FMCG & CPG industry.

More from SmashBrand

Strategy, Design, Testing

The ROI of packaging: How to design CPG packs that win with consumers.

Failing to give packaging design its proper due isn’t just a missed opportunity —…

Strategy, Design, Testing

How data-driven package design mitigates the risks of rebranding and boosts ROI.

Rebranding always comes with risks, especially when it comes to updating your CPG pack….

Positioning, Innovation

CPG Product Line Stretching For Increased Market Share.

When Cadbury launched its instant mashed potatoes, we had a clear example of where…

Strategy

7 CPG Brand Dilution Examples And How To Avoid It.

When Dr. Pepper launched its BBQ sauce, customers were scratching their heads, wondering how…

Testing

Use consumer-tested packaging design to crack the code of impulse purchases.

For many FMCG brands, impulse purchases are the primary means of attracting new consumers…

Strategy

A Complete Roadmap For Brand Voice Development

According to recent statistics, 77% of consumers prefer shopping with brands they follow on…