Brand development that increases sales velocity, guaranteed.

Matching the Ceiling to the Carpet

If you have a multitude of bar piercings, horn implants, tattoos and earlobe plates, your career as a neurosurgeon, lawyer or funeral director could suffer. In fact, your choice of adornment happens to be perfectly suited to the clients of the aforementioned professionals (head trauma victim, criminal or corpse, respectively).

Judgmental? Perhaps, but we nonetheless must outfit ourselves in a matter commonly accepted to befit the profession of our choice if we are to be trusted by potential customers. You may be the most brilliant accountant in the world, but if you dress like you just escaped the clutches of Dog the Bounty Hunter, very few people will trust you with their money. The same basic rule applies for websites.

Our examples are extreme, of course, but they nonetheless illustrate the point that clients respond warmly to a website whose services, products, personality and brand are easily identifiable, and simply aren’t interested in discovering the inner workings of a challenging exterior. If you own a restaurant chain, your website better feature photos and descriptions of delicious food. If you are a photographer, your website better have examples of beautifully composed photographs. If you are an espionage agent, your site should have pictures of you not existing.

Does this mean that every website has to be predictable and coma-inducing in its sameness? Of course not! But a good designer will find a way to navigate the particular parameters of a business category and give the customer base what it expects, but what it hasn’t seen before at the same time. Confusing? Welcome to the big boy’s club, pal.

Walking the Line

Website personality has more to do with branding than with product, and quite frankly, a Web designer has very little input into the client’s branding strategy. Oh sure, a new business may look for brand consulting services, but a designer isn’t going to convince a staid financial institution to abandon its blue-blooded image and suddenly embrace the emo/Morrissey aesthetic.

The trick is to give the client exactly what he/she wants, with a soupcon of something that will make his/her enterprise stand out. Yes, you must yield to the brand almighty, but there is more than one way to skin a cat.

Take, for example, the Dr. Bronner’s line of liquid soaps. Now, this isn’t a website, but it is an example of how a product that is quite straightforward has benefitted by a touch of quirkiness. The famous soap bottle is chock full of text which, if you bother to read it, is basically the fractured ramblings of a failed cult leader (a nice cult leader, mind you). However, because not everybody actually reads it, it just looks like a kind of crowded, old-timey product label that evokes the image of a general store with a gingham-wearing proprietress. The brand could have actually created a logo featuring a gingham-wearing proprietress, but they went a unique route that achieves basically the same thing, plus a little bit more. Creative? Darned straight.

Edging away from the Line

No one’s saying that you shouldn’t, under any circumstances, design anything that isn’t instantly familiar; we’re just saying that association is key. If you’ve figured out a way to bridge an unusual image or aesthetic to a particular service in a logical and interesting manner, then by all means, do it. However, it is nonetheless critical for the design choice to make sense within the context of what is being advertised. Sadly, “edgy” isn’t necessarily appropriate for every client.

The vast majority of potential clients offer services that are inherently unexciting; they will be medical supply renters, septic system maintenance technicians or mold remediation and testing services. Clients of this sort aren’t looking for ways to entice young customers – they want a website that makes them look respectable, honest, hardworking and skilled.

So, what have we learned today? We’ve learned that branding is more important than product when it comes to web design. We learned that a website needs to communicate the core principles of the brand and service in a clean, succinct and evocative manner. Most importantly, we learned that as far as we’ve come in terms of overcoming outward appearances, we would advise against hiring a lawyer with a faux hawk and a 2 gauge septum piercing (10 gauge is fine, though).

Data-Driven Brand Development

Want a best-selling brand? SmashBrand is a brand development agency for FMCG and CPG companies. From brand strategy to packaging design testing, our Path To Performance™ process guarantees a retail performance lift. Book a time to discuss your project with our team.

Subscribe to
Nice Package.

SmashBrand’s Nice Package: Stay current with our latest insights

Free Resource.
CPG product repositioning guide.
CPG product repositioning guide.

Explore the five undeniable signs your CPG product needs repositioning along with strategies for leveraging consumer insights for a guaranteed market lift.

Download Whitepaper About CPG product repositioning guide.

More from SmashBrand

NICE PACKAGE, Design

The Problem with Packaging Design That Looks Different.

Most brands chase standout visuals without asking a harder question, does it make the product easier to recognize and buy? That gap kills performance. If your design stands out but doesn’t convert, it’s failing. Want to see why? Read on.

Category Insights, Shopping With Christy

Why Rao’s Soup Misses the Mark on This Packaging Design.

Brand extension can be a powerful growth strategy, but only if it’s executed with clarity. In this case, the transition from pasta sauce into soup creates confusion rather than differentiation. The biggest issue is visual overlap. Using the same jar, color palette, and overall look as the pasta sauce line makes it difficult to immediately…

Category Insights

This Retail Display Tells You Everything About a Brand in Trouble

When packaging starts working against the brand, it shows up quickly, especially on the shelf. In this case, the execution creates confusion instead of clarity. The most immediate issue is readability. If shoppers can’t quickly identify the brand name or fully read the tagline, the pack loses its primary job: recognition. “Thirst’s worst” is a…

Category Insights

Why This Parent and CPG Marketer Secretly Loves This “White” Bread

Sometimes the most powerful packaging change is verbal. A single line of copy can unlock the entire value proposition. In this case, the product already solved a real consumer tension: the desire for healthier bread that still feels and tastes like white bread. But previously, that benefit was implied rather than stated. Shoppers had to…

Category Insights

Wait, Sargento Makes Crackers Now? Not Exactly

Brand extensions only work when trust transfers seamlessly, and that’s where this execution creates friction. At first glance, the product signals cheese, not crackers. The name, visuals, and dominant cues all lean heavily into cheese equity, leaving the actual product format unclear. That confusion matters. Shoppers rely on quick recognition, and if they can’t immediately…

Category Insights

Is Coke Lime making a Comeback?

Limited-time innovation only works if timing and design align with consumer expectations. A citrus-forward cola immediately signals refreshment, which is typically associated with warmer months. Launching that profile in October creates a subtle disconnect, even if the execution is strong. From a strategy standpoint, this is a classic line extension play, leveraging an existing brand…