If Shoppers Can’t Place Your Product In A Second, They’ll Walk.

When your product is a true innovation, the hardest job isn’t design—it’s giving consumers the right frame of reference. This clip breaks down how we create instant understanding, even for products the market’s never seen before.

Description

Breakthrough innovation fails when the frame of reference is wrong.

If a new product feels like “Ben Gay” or “Icy Hot” in a consumer’s mind, that’s the shortcut they’ll use, no matter how different it actually is. That’s why subcategory innovation is harder than launching a slightly more premium version of something familiar. You’re not just selling benefits. You’re redefining what the product is.

In this case, the solution wasn’t better claims. It was reframing the category. Instead of competing with muscle rubs, the product was positioned like sunscreen. “Cold Screen.” With its own version of SPF: Cold Protection Factor.

That simple shift gave consumers a mental model they already understood. And once the shortcut made sense, the product did too.

Great packaging and positioning don’t just explain innovation. They anchor it to something familiar so the brain can say yes faster.

Video Transcript

00:00:00 What is the consumer's frame of
00:00:02 reference? If you're just another
00:00:04 product that's like slightly higher
00:00:05 premium, it's pretty easy and you can
00:00:07 jump straight to like what is it that
00:00:09 makes your more premium, but like in
00:00:11 your case, Jordan, and a lot of really
00:00:13 good product innovation happens by kind
00:00:15 of merging or kind of switching and kind
00:00:18 of subcategory innovation. And those are
00:00:20 the harder ones where you actually have
00:00:21 to really get the frame of reference
00:00:23 right. This actually reminds me of a
00:00:25 client we had many, many years ago. And
00:00:26 this one was pretty fun because the
00:00:28 product was very much an innovation and
00:00:31 I'm gonna explain what it is. You tell
00:00:32 me what comes to mind. Okay. So this is
00:00:35 how you use it actually. This is the
00:00:36 kind of the use case. So maybe I'm going
00:00:38 skiing and you know gets chilly in the
00:00:40 end. So I have this lotion. I'm going to
00:00:42 rub it on my skin or maybe I'm live in
00:00:45 New York City female. I got a nice dress
00:00:46 on and I don't want to wear the big
00:00:48 bulky clothes on a cold evening. So I
00:00:50 put this lotion on my skin. So what
00:00:51 comes to mind to you when you think of
00:00:53 that? You know, it kind of sounds like
00:00:54 icy hot but the hot.
00:00:55 >> Yes. And that's the problem. This is a
00:00:57 perfect example. You don't have a frame
00:00:59 of reference. And so the client came to
00:01:02 us. They're like, "Oh yeah, this
00:01:03 product, everybody likes it after we
00:01:05 explain it, but they always just like
00:01:06 think of Ben Gay." This was a really
00:01:08 tricky one, but I think it kind of it's
00:01:10 an exaggerated point, but it's a real
00:01:12 example of how the consumer needs to
00:01:14 kind of shortcuts. And so what's the
00:01:16 decision-making shortcut? In their case,
00:01:18 we actually had to change the whole
00:01:19 frame of reference, and we called it
00:01:21 cold screen. So your frame of reference
00:01:23 is now sunscreen, cold screen. And then
00:01:24 they had like SPF which was like CPFs
00:01:27 cold protection factor.

Packaging design case studies: Tree Top boosted parent trust and kid appeal with new packaging.

Mary Marnell Director of Content & Marketing

13 Articles

A seasoned veteran in the CPG (Consumer Packaged Goods) industry, Jason Vaught brings a wealth of knowledge and hands-on experience as the director of content and marketing for SmashBrand. His comprehensive role at the forefront of brand communication ensures that CPG brands remain well-informed about the suite of services SmashBrand offers. Furthermore, his insights derived from the company's strategy, design, and testing services are invaluable to brand owners and managers seeking expert guidance.

Learn more

Subscribe to
Nice Package.

SmashBrand’s Nice Package: Stay current with our latest insights

Free Resource.

CPG product repositioning guide.

Explore the five undeniable signs your CPG product needs repositioning along with strategies for leveraging consumer insights for a guaranteed market lift.

Download Whitepaper About CPG product repositioning guide.

Front-of-pack messaging isn’t guesswork. It’s a formula.

Clarity wins at shelf. In this clip, we dive into the hierarchy of communication—what needs to be seen first, what can wait, and how we test to find the sequence that drives purchase.⁠

Every winning product earns these two things

Every winning product earns two things: the consumer’s heart and their head.

Why This Heinz Display Is Driving Me Crazy!

At Target’s pickle and olive aisle, Christy spots a Heinz Relish squeeze bottle… upside down in its merchandising tray. This quick shelf check shows how small mistakes at retail impact brand presentation—and how much better a product can look when faced correctly.

Why KitKat’s Churro Flavor Display Is a Masterclass in Shelf Impact

What makes a display drive trial? In this quick Walmart walkthrough, Christy explains how KitKat nails limited-edition branding with a low-cost, high-impact PDQ. From a strategic cutout to smart graphic layering, these subtle design details drive instant recognition, and that means more grabs off the shelf.

View More Category Insights

Follow Christy

Follow Christy for real-world shopper insights, brand wins, and weekly takes on what’s working in retail.

Follow Christy on

Subscribe on YouTube

Subscribe on YouTube for daily brand insights, shelf-winning strategies, and weekly retail breakdowns.

Don’t miss our Newsletter