Brand development that increases sales velocity, guaranteed.

Your How-to Guide for Choosing the Right Packaging Material.

Those of us who aren’t designers only think of product packaging materials as an enticement or a hindrance. If the material can be used for other important purposes, it’s an enticement. If the material is indestructible plastic used for clamshell packaging and can’t be opened without a Samurai sword, it’s a hindrance.

As a public service, we’re offering you a concise how-to guide for finding the best materials for packaging your product, so long as your product is a food item of some sort. If we were to go into all of the items in the world that merited retail packaging design of some kind, we might be forced to exceed 750 words.

What is my budget?

Before you begin any packaging endeavor, you must determine the scope of your budget, as this will determine whether you will be able to use material of some kind or force your customers to scoop kale chips into their bare hands.

For the wealthy brand, there is always glass, natural fibers and shredded $100 bills reconstituted into standing tin-tie bags. But most small brands will be unable to afford such luxuries and rely upon standard bulk-item materials from which enticing retail package designs must be fashioned. Many budget-friendly packaging options offer superlative protection for food products. Food-grade cardboard is a relatively inexpensive material that offers reasonable crush protection and interesting design opportunities. Bio-based food packaging made from renewable organic sources is an even more reasonably priced alternative. Of course, your ultimate decision will be based on the type of food you’re packaging, which leads us to the question:

What type of product am I packaging?

Is your product vulnerable to crushing, like potato chips or crackers? Will the package affect the product’s potential for spoilage? Will it have to be refrigerated or frozen? Can it be stored at room temperature before opening and subsequently refrigerated? Is it liquid? Solid? Vapor?

Determining the best packaging materials for your food product will largely involve science. For different food items, one enemy might be microbes, while another might be oxidation. Carbonated beverages must be packaged in materials that can withstand CO2 pressure, such as glass or PET. Still, a cardboard “can”is also being distributed in Europe that seems quite impressive.

How is my packaging being stored?

Will your retail product packaging endure thousands of miles of travel over harsh terrain in stifling heat or blistering cold? Will the product have to endure severe changes in temperature before it reaches store shelves?

If your product is being distributed all over the United States or even internationally, the packaging must withstand all climates and altitudes. The packaging material is the literal and figurative barrier between product loss and sales.

What is my message?

The type of material your product uses for retail packaging is a part of your overarching brand statement. Any disconnect between the type of material you use for your packaging and your brand identity will lead customers to believe that your entire brand mission statement could be a big, fat lie.

If your brand prides itself on being folksy and local, you probably want to source many, if not all, of your materials from local distributors. If your brand prides itself on being eco-friendly, vegetarian/vegan friendly, gluten-intolerant friendly and all-around swell, your packaging can’t harm the environment one iota. This means that if harmful petrochemicals leach from the plastics into local rivers and streams during manufacture, it will become a PR nightmare for your brand.

The retail food market is beyond competitive — frighteningly so. The biggest deciding factor for whether your food product moves off of store shelves and into the hands of the consumer is the retail product packaging. The firm you choose to design product packaging for your brand and the material you choose could make or break the entire concept. No pressure, though.

Data-Driven Brand Development

Want a best-selling brand? SmashBrand is a brand development company for FMCG and CPG brands. From brand strategy to packaging design testing, our Path To Performance™ process guarantees a retail performance lift. Book a time to discuss your project with our team.

Subscribe to
Nice Package.

SmashBrand’s Nice Package: Stay current with our latest insights

Free Resource.
CPG product repositioning guide.
CPG product repositioning guide.

Explore the five undeniable signs your CPG product needs repositioning along with strategies for leveraging consumer insights for a guaranteed market lift.

Download Whitepaper About CPG product repositioning guide.

More from SmashBrand

NICE PACKAGE, Design

The Problem with Packaging Design That Looks Different.

Most brands chase standout visuals without asking a harder question, does it make the product easier to recognize and buy? That gap kills performance. If your design stands out but doesn’t convert, it’s failing. Want to see why? Read on.

Category Insights, Shopping With Christy

Why Rao’s Soup Misses the Mark on This Packaging Design.

Brand extension can be a powerful growth strategy, but only if it’s executed with clarity. In this case, the transition from pasta sauce into soup creates confusion rather than differentiation. The biggest issue is visual overlap. Using the same jar, color palette, and overall look as the pasta sauce line makes it difficult to immediately…

Category Insights

This Retail Display Tells You Everything About a Brand in Trouble

When packaging starts working against the brand, it shows up quickly, especially on the shelf. In this case, the execution creates confusion instead of clarity. The most immediate issue is readability. If shoppers can’t quickly identify the brand name or fully read the tagline, the pack loses its primary job: recognition. “Thirst’s worst” is a…

Category Insights

Why This Parent and CPG Marketer Secretly Loves This “White” Bread

Sometimes the most powerful packaging change is verbal. A single line of copy can unlock the entire value proposition. In this case, the product already solved a real consumer tension: the desire for healthier bread that still feels and tastes like white bread. But previously, that benefit was implied rather than stated. Shoppers had to…

Category Insights

Wait, Sargento Makes Crackers Now? Not Exactly

Brand extensions only work when trust transfers seamlessly, and that’s where this execution creates friction. At first glance, the product signals cheese, not crackers. The name, visuals, and dominant cues all lean heavily into cheese equity, leaving the actual product format unclear. That confusion matters. Shoppers rely on quick recognition, and if they can’t immediately…

Category Insights

Is Coke Lime making a Comeback?

Limited-time innovation only works if timing and design align with consumer expectations. A citrus-forward cola immediately signals refreshment, which is typically associated with warmer months. Launching that profile in October creates a subtle disconnect, even if the execution is strong. From a strategy standpoint, this is a classic line extension play, leveraging an existing brand…