Brand development that increases sales velocity, guaranteed.

The Seven Cardinal Sins of Package Design.

It’s no secret that many industries don’t exactly steer their ships according to the moral compass. Perhaps those experimenting on animals, polluting the environment, or employing child labor come to mind. While we in the product design and branding field stay away from these unquestionably despicable practices, we don’t all have untarnished halos.

Package designers are fallible too; even the new, way cooler Pope would concur. And while we generally stick to the venial sins for which we can atone with a couple Hail Marys and an extra fiver in the collection plate, we’ve also been known to commit the occasional big kahuna of wickedness. Let’s look at the seven cardinal sins of package design.

Packaging Design Sin #1: Pride

Did you know that pride is generally considered the original cardinal sin and the source of all the others? For package designers, pride is unforgivable when it lets you rest on your laurels. In the ever-changing field of package design, it’s definitely a cardinal sin to think it’s not your responsibility to stay up on the latest trends and developments in the industry. You don’t want to see your clients’ products staying on retailers’ shelves while watching better-packaged goods making their way to the checkout. It’s your charge to stay up on the latest advances. If you don’t, it will take more than a Hail Mary to save your bottom line.

Packaging Design Sin #2: Lust

While pride prevents you from acknowledging others’ worth because you’re so fixated on your superiority, lust may make you too engrossed in your competitors. Acknowledging another brand’s seriously sexy design is no sin; we’d be lying if we said Apple’s packaging doesn’t sometimes give us the tingles. But you can take it too far if you convince yourself that what works for a competitor is right for you. Smart design requires investing in what makes products unique. Acknowledge the accomplishments of others without lusting after someone else’s work, and your own designs will have the chance to shine.

Packaging Design Sin #3: Sloth

Oh man, this one’s a doozie. Sloth is laziness, plain and simple. It’s not only a deadly sin in the package design sphere; this is an equal opportunity offense. Lazy package designers recycle the same tired themes repeatedly, slowly amassing a pile of vaguely similar but oddly uninteresting products with no distinguishing features. Get your butt in gear and be bold with branding and design. Your clients – and your coffers – will thank you!

Packaging Design Sin #4: Greed

Hey, Ebenezer, let the other kids play with the Monopoly money! If you’re guilty of thinking that your firm can handle ALL THE CLIENTS, you’re wrong. The best package designers know that not every brand matches their skillsets well. You don’t have to have the maximum number of clients possible; that’s greedy and unwise. We think excellent packaging design is a partnership between the product or line and the packaging design firm. We’re discerning about the brands we develop because package design is not an exact science. We want to give all our clients our fullest attention so that the design process results in the most dynamic packaging possible.

Packaging Design Sin #5: Envy

When we see covet-worthy product packaging, it makes us want to sing the Hallelujah chorus. In a field crowded with awkward, overly complicated, or just plain ugly packaging, we’re happy to acknowledge the achievements of skilled package designers – even our competitors – when they hit a home run. Don’t hate the player, hate the fact that you didn’t come up with something better — and then go do it. We don’t let envy bring us down; we eat it for breakfast, get motivated, and come out swinging (but not like a bad Rocky knockoff, sorry “Grudge Match”).

Packaging Design Sin #6: Gluttony

Too much of a good thing is actually a bad thing if you haven’t guessed. Gluttonous designers of packaging are unfamiliar with the concept of simplicity. We design for the client and the public, not to tickle our own graphical fancy. So don’t over-design packaging to the detriment of the product. Or else, you may spend eternity gorging on humble pie.

Packaging Design Sin #7: Pride

The final cardinal sin of package design (that we’ll admit to) is actually committed not by the designers themselves but by frustrated consumers who become borderline homicidal when attempting to open overly complicated packaging. If you’ve created such a design, you’re an accessory to the sin of wrath. Excellence in design walks the line between beauty and functionality. Repeat offenders of overly complicated packaging design are doomed to an afterlife of opening clamshell packages with no scissors. No mercy.

Data-Driven Brand Development

Want a best-selling brand? SmashBrand is a brand development firm for FMCG and CPG companies. From brand strategy to packaging design testing, our Path To Performance™ process guarantees a retail performance lift. Book a time to discuss your project with our team.

Subscribe to
Nice Package.

SmashBrand’s Nice Package: Stay current with our latest insights

Free Resource.
CPG product repositioning guide.
CPG product repositioning guide.

Explore the five undeniable signs your CPG product needs repositioning along with strategies for leveraging consumer insights for a guaranteed market lift.

Download Whitepaper About CPG product repositioning guide.

More from SmashBrand

Shopping With Christy

When Cereal Becomes Art And Branding Becomes Culture

What happens when consumer culture meets fine art? At Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art, KAWS reimagines General Mills’ Monster Cereals showing us the power of nostalgia. In this video, Christy explores how CPG brands can transcend the aisle and shape cultural memory.

Shopping With Christy

Will This Limited-time Offer Drive Conversions?

Ritz’s summer-themed innovation baked to a crisp. Christy breaks down this seasonal SKU where playful packaging meets mixed messaging.

Shopping With Christy

Barebells protein bar lookin like Rolo’s?

In this packaging breakdown, Christy explores Barebells’ latest SKU spotted at Target. This new box structure offers a visual identity that leans heavily into confectionery cues. Is it a subtle strategy to draft off category-adjacent equity, or the beginning of a broader brand evolution?

Shopping With Christy

Gatorade Extends Into Alkaline Water

Gatorade recently entered the branded water category. Here’s what works, what doesn’t, and what your brand can learn when developing a brand extension. From equity transfer to packaging differentiation, we break down how this launch leverages built-in credibility and whether it delivers clear category understanding.

Shopping With Christy

Why This Is A Missed Opportunity!

Shelf visibility matters more than category familiarity. When a shopper doesn’t instantly understand what a product is, the package has already failed its first job. This example shows a common issue with DTC packaging design when it moves into retail. What works online, small logos, text-led explanations, subtle cues, often collapses on the shelf. In…

Shopping With Christy

Dr Pepper Baked Beans… smart licensing play?

Unexpected brand pairings are one of the fastest ways to stop a shopper mid-aisle, when they make sense. This baked beans SKU does exactly that by borrowing equity from a household-name soda brand and dropping it into a place most people wouldn’t expect to see it. From a food packaging design perspective, the move works…